<img alt="" src="http://ny-image0.etsy.com/il_155x125.72581408.jpg" class="alignnone" width="155" height="125" />
I came across this seller <a href="http://www.etsy.com/shop.php?user_id=6506718">http://www.etsy.com/shop.php?user_id=6506718</a> and feel really hacked off that she is just copying classic work by EH Shepard for Winnie the Pooh,

for example, just one of many, hers – <a href="http://www.etsy.com/view_listing.php?listing_id=25739434">http://www.etsy.com/view_listing.php?listing_id=25739434</a>

original – <a href="http://www.just-pooh.com/pictures-view.html?id=427">http://www.just-pooh.com/pictures-view.html?id=427</a>

and Helen Oxenbury for Alice

hers – <a href="http://www.etsy.com/view_listing.php?ref=vl_other_1&amp;listing_id=23610441">http://www.etsy.com/view_listing.php?ref=vl_other_1&amp;listing_id=23610441</a>

original – <a href="http://www.amazon.com/Alices-Adventures-Wonderland-Lewis-Carroll/dp/0763620491">http://www.amazon.com/Alices-Adventures-Wonderland-Lewis-Carroll/dp/0763620491</a>

She says: “All of my artwork is Original and hand painted”, and never gives a name check to the real original artists or acknowledges they are copies. She might as well just use a light box.

I reported one of her items, but nothing happened.
__________________________________________________________________________________________
I would love to see what Disney thought of her "originals".

Looking at her sold items I see she has copied Nightmare Before Christmas and Curious George as well..

35 comments:

  1. By "original" I think she means they're not prints.

    Wacky & Tacky Etsy

  2. Wow, that is flagrant! I reported her to Disney.

    Wacky & Tacky Etsy

  3. how on earth can this be legal?
    it's not in the public domain and just 100% uncool as well

    Wacky & Tacky Etsy

  4. Hey dummies she means originals as in they are not prints they are painted reproductions. Get your facts straight!

    Wacky & Tacky Etsy

  5. Thanks for clearing that up, Pete. However, reproduction is not original. She's reproducing copyrighted work for profit (that's illegal, BTW, Pete).

    We know what she means but she should be saying something like, "I handpaint each piece I sell." There's nothing original when it comes to plagiarism.

    Wacky & Tacky Etsy

  6. Hey dummy, you can't call a reproduction an original. And you can't reproduce another artist's work, that is copyright. Get your facts straight SLC.

    Wacky & Tacky Etsy

  7. Actually, you can reproduce another artist's work. Plenty of large companies make a living off of it while complying with the copyright law. They reproduce the work of painters such as Van Gogh and Monet in great detail. Here's an example:

    http://www.fabulousmasterpieces.co.uk/

    But here's the catch, copyright lasts for the lifetime of the artist plus 70 years. So you'll need to make sure the artist you're copying kicked the bucket in 1939 or so.

    Wacky & Tacky Etsy

  8. copyright can also be left to your family in a will and therefore last through your remaining heirs ad infinitum. just b/c someone kicked the bucket in 1939 would not just open up the artwork to the public domain.it's complex

    in certain art forms it is the life of the artist + 125 years

    what is just a dazzling display of cheek is to duplicate these illustrations. a total wjw.

    Wacky & Tacky Etsy

  9. It is complex. But either way, Helen Oxenbury is still alive and EH Shepard passed away in the 70's. Has anyone sent regs123 a convo on Etsy?

    Wacky & Tacky Etsy

  10. http://www.hundred-acre-woods.ws/faq/chapter2.htm

    "2.7 What's the copyright status on the stories?

    All the original Pooh stories by A.A. Milne are still under copyright protection. Here's the explanation from Christopher Franceschelli, president of Dutton Children's Books.

    'Under the copyright laws of the United States, for all works published prior to 1978, copyright protection extends for seventy-five years after the date of first publication. _Winnie-the-Pooh_ was published in 1926, and is therefore protected by copyright until after the turn of the century. There are several elements, e.g. the colored illustrations of the Ernest Shepard drawings, in which copyright protection is extended to well beyond the middle of the next century. In the United Kingdom and in other countries subscribing to the Berne Convention, copyright extends for an even longer period than in the United States.

    Copyright in the text by A.A. Milne and in the illustrations by Ernest Shepard resides jointly or individually in the Trustees of the Pooh Properties, Dutton Children's Books (a division of Penguin USA) and Methuen Children's Books (a division of Reed Consumer Books) and all three rights holders are committed to protecting the copyright fully. (The proliferation of various items of Pooh merchandise is not due to the books being out-of-copyright, but rather our recognition that there are indeed many Friends of the Bear who welcome the availability of more Pooh materials, and we have therefore, together with the fourth _Pooh_ rights holder, the Walt Disney Company, created or have licensed several ranges authorized merchandise in both book and non-book form.)

    Therefore, the reproduction of any of A.A. Milne's text beyond that of fair use (as it is defined under the copyright law) or of the line or color illustrations by Ernest Shepard on the home page or any ancillary pages as they appear there currently or in future without prior and proper permission by the rights holders is a breach of both U.S. and international copyright law.'

    U.S. copyright protection was extended to a period of 95 years for any works still under protection as of October 27, 1998. This means that "Winnie-the-Pooh" will be under copyright protection until October 21, 2021, in the United States."

    Wacky & Tacky Etsy

  11. What had upset me so much about it was there was no acknowledgement that these were the copies of other artists.

    I think if she'd said - 'I love the work of EH Shepard, Helen Oxenbury (and whoever else) and I make these hand made reproductions of their work' - I would've thought well, that's an honestly declaration, and I probably would've left it at that.

    As it is, the implication throughout her carefully worded shop is - These are my own originals.

    I wondered if she assumed the US buyers would be more familiar with the modern Disney versions and that she could get away with copying Shepard (the illustrator of the AA Milne books) and passing them off as her own.

    Wacky & Tacky Etsy

  12. honestly declaration = honestly made declaration

    Wacky & Tacky Etsy

  13. shop is now 'on vacation'!

    Wacky & Tacky Etsy

  14. I'm sorry. I saw this today and it's just too funny to keep to myself!
    http://www.etsy.com/shop.php?user_id=7651757

    Her shop announcement and all her listings say "Not Handmade"!

    Wacky & Tacky Etsy

  15. She wants to finance a move to Montreal by selling her gently used thongs and bras....wjw.

    Wacky & Tacky Etsy

  16. at least bedazzle the bras or something....

    Wacky & Tacky Etsy

  17. It worked for condoms!

    Wacky & Tacky Etsy

  18. Wow, WTH? Everything is maked not handmade; she didn't even try to mark it vintage (though I know thongs weren't too popular 20+ years ago)......why is it still up after 10 days? I tagged it!

    Wacky & Tacky Etsy

  19. On the seller with the Disney stuff . . . Disney will go after them in a freakin' heartbeat. They have a team of people who do nothing but go after these kinds of merchants.

    Wacky & Tacky Etsy

  20. OMG, Brandye! That is hilarious.

    Wacky & Tacky Etsy

  21. Brand new Chanel purse sold on Etsy:

    http://www.etsy.com/view_listing.php?listing_id=25862534

    Wacky & Tacky Etsy

  22. original means original i.e. from the artist's brush, pen, mind, imagination, etc. it is the first. a reproduction is a reproduction whether it is painted or printed. what that seller is doing is shameful. the fine artists on etsy are working hard to get the site to reorganize the sub-categories of art and eliminate mistagging- ( not to mention eliminating copying or rather, stealing another artist's work).

    Wacky & Tacky Etsy

  23. etsy probably wont move too fast on this one- prints are one of their largest sellers. forcing sellers to stop tagging their prints as "originals" aint going to happen. so many have made their argument that their prints are the original work of the artist- even though they are prints- printed over and over again on a fancy printer but still prints nonetheless

    although this seller is an entirely different issue- claiming someone else's original works as her own is theft of copyright or trademark or whatever and probably will not be allowed after appearing on this blog

    Wacky & Tacky Etsy

  24. I think that is is funny how people spend their time venting on etsy sellers when they don't have the guts to confront the sellers personally. I think it's incredibly cowardly to talk behind people's backs the way some of you do. Especially when comments are completely anonymous. Whats the point of this website? Go to ebay and type in Disney art and you will find thousands of artists selling their own disney paintings. This happens all the time. Disney is too busy, wealthy and large a company to spend time hunting down copycats.

    -Hi Reagan :) Miss Lightbox herself. You might want to be a little more on the down low when you are slapping hands for wrong doing -eco

    Wacky & Tacky Etsy

  25. Oh boo, like that makes it ok, Megan? Everyone's doing it so it's ok....meh. And aren't you anonymous too? Hello??

    Wacky & Tacky Etsy

  26. Ten bucks says "Megan" lives in Salt Lake City.

    -$10 are coming your way :) -eco

    Wacky & Tacky Etsy

  27. Oh, and "Megan?"

    "Copyright in the text by A.A. Milne and in the illustrations by Ernest Shepard resides jointly or individually in the Trustees of the Pooh Properties, Dutton Children’s Books (a division of Penguin USA) and Methuen Children’s Books (a division of Reed Consumer Books) AND ALL THREE RIGHTS HOLDERS ARE COMMITTED TO PROTECTING THE COPYRIGHT FULLY."

    We don't need no stinkin' Disney, chica.

    Wacky & Tacky Etsy

  28. Disney goes after even the smallest infringement. A preschool nearby had two Disney characters painted on a wall. They were contacted by Disney and had to remove them.

    Stealing is stealing. Those thousands of ebay Disney copies are thousands of stolen art pieces.

    Wacky & Tacky Etsy

  29. "Illustrations by Ernest H. Shepard. Illustrations are copyright protected and used by permission of the Executor of E.H. Shepard and the E.H. Shepard."

    Man-oh-man the Penguin/Dutton website contact us/email options are so fucking inadequate and confusing.

    I may have to make a phone call.

    Wacky & Tacky Etsy

  30. Or.....

    http://twitter.com/PenguinUSA

    Wacky & Tacky Etsy

  31. Megan - I think toonces makes a good point.

    The natural conclusion to what you say is: I may do anything - ANYTHING - provided other folks have already done it.

    That's potentially pretty dangerous, eh?

    The thing is - what's YOUR moral code? And what IS decent behaviour anyhow?

    Wacky & Tacky Etsy

  32. i'm really disappointed (if this was the same person,i.e.:Megan/Seller) if you willingly and knowingly made a copy, knowing it was wrong.

    or should i appreciate your cheek?

    hmmm

    Wacky & Tacky Etsy

  33. "Everyone else is doing it" is the most pathetic way to live your life. Have some fucking integrity.

    Wacky & Tacky Etsy

  34. "-$10 are coming your way -eco"

    Normally, I would gloat about being right but in this case, it's depressing to be right.

    Wacky & Tacky Etsy

  35. And people wonder why art collectors shun Etsy.

    Wacky & Tacky Etsy

Post a Comment